Mahony vs. Gumbleton

The ever pugnacious NEW OXFORD REVIEW is not known for fawning over anyone, no matter what. The editors dish out equally biting criticism for the good guys (Neuhaus, Fessio, Hahn) as well as for the bad guys (McBrien, Weakland, Kung).

When it comes to a comparison between two well known "liberal" U.S. bishops, however, who in the minds of the editors of NOR is the more respectable, MAHONY or GUMBLETON?

Go HERE for the answer.